Senators Demand Answers About Alarming Reports of Excessive and Risky Artery Procedures on Veterans, Help ProPublica and The Salt Lake Tribune Investigate Sexual Assault in Utah, If youre republishing online, you must link to the URL of this story on propublica.org, include all of the links from our story, including our newsletter sign up language and link, and use our. Case Status: Active, DAILY REPORT #2019-134 RPT: 0846 5-1-19 OCC: 0815 4-30-19 to 1630 4-30-19 RPT: 2042 5-3-19 OCC: 2042 5-3-19 to 2042 5-3-19 Heres Why a Judge Threw Out Their Case. . 4. there must be a reason outside the control of law enforcement which prevents the arrest, exceptional clearances should be reported under one of the following five circumstances once the previous conditions have been met, 1. death of the offender Corey Rayburn Yung, a law professor at the University of Kansas who studies criminal law procedure and sex crimes, said statistics-driven policing has created scandal after scandal when its discovered that law enforcement agencies have gamed their numbers related to how they process rape cases. Case Status: Suspended, THREATENING E-MAIL 583 Brandon Avenue 201916432/15 Case Status: Active, DAILY REPORT #2019-148 Reported a crash in parking lot with a state vehicle The case file went to Detective Dana Kaczynski, who did not interview the suspect or attempt to arrest him. RPT: 2225 5-11-19 OCC: 2107 5-11-19 to 2225 5-11-19 Case Status: Active, LARCENY 64 Lambeth Commons 201915942/69 When prosecutors decline cases in which police have identified a suspect and have probable cause to make an arrest, the police can exceptionally clear the case. to questions 1, 2, and 3 in the Exceptionally Cleared section.) 98 0 obj <> endobj To clear an offense within the UCR Programs guidelines, the reporting agency must adhere to certain criteria, which are outlined in the following text. The reporters can be reached at [emailprotected], [emailprotected], [emailprotected] and [emailprotected]. SIMPLE ASSULT 1215 Lee Street 201919262/16 For every case they resolved through arrest, Oakland police cleared more than three by exceptional means, data provided by the department shows. Reported a lost motorized irrigation system Case Status: Suspended, LOST PROPERTY 1204 West Main Street 201916534/67 Reported a stolen hard drive Reported an assist citizen and drunk in public D = Victim Refused to Cooperate (in the prosecution). For a while, the girl borrowed her friends phones at school to chat with Kind until he sent her a new one, which she kept under her mattress. Case Status: Suspended, HIT AND RUN 400 Emmet St NO PI 201919707/37 Prosecutors offices are equally under pressure to keep their conviction rates high, even if it means passing on more cases than they should, he said. Reported an accident Reported damage to vehicle Reported possession of marijuana Reported a stolen moped Case Status: Cleared by arrest, ASSIST CITIZEN 295 Massie Road 201917010/23 In contrast, of the 52.5 percent of aggravated assault cases that were cleared, prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of cases. The state clearance rate, lower than the 39.6% rate for 2019, continues to be consistently higher than the national average of approximately 21.5% (2019 data). RPT: 1028 5-7-19 OCC: 2030 5-6-2019 to 2030 5-6-19 When Baltimore County reviewed the case at our request, spokesman Shawn Vinson said the department in fact didnt have probable cause to make an arrest. Reported juvenile left hospital, was found and returned Case Status: Active, POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA Jefferson Park Ave/Ruppel Dr 201917160/66 If were losing a really critical piece of information in that process, I will not have done my job appropriately.. Its not truthful.. RPT: 1107 5-23-2019 OCC: 1630 5-18-2019 to 1630 5-18-2019 When we told Conner how her case was closed, she was outraged. RPT: 0254 5-23-2019 OCC: 0254 5-23-2019 to 0254 5-23-2019 RPT: 2134 5-10-19 OCC: 2134 5-10-19 Reported a vehicle accident no damage or injury Reported vehicle accident exchange of info hbbd```b``Nd>d3H309LH&N\0&oeY]@1$ "xzA(4$GC? c The department said the rates jumped after it discovered some cases were being misclassified as suspended instead of exceptionally cleared because victims didnt cooperate with the investigation. This would make the case an improper use of exceptional clearance. Case Status: Exceptionally cleared; prosecution declined RPT: 0739 5-2-19 OCC: 1400 5-1-19 to 1430 5-1-19 Of the 34.5 percent of rape and sexual assault cases that were cleared, 59.2 percent were due to arrest and 13.8 percent were due to victims refusing to cooperate. Case Status: Suspended, PROPERTY DAMAGE 1215 Lee Street 201915848/59 Case Status: Suspended, STOLEN PROPERTY 110 Bayly Drive 201917289/69 Donegan says she never changed the clearance numbers as she was asked. Any case involving a warrant which is issued by a judge while the Cases are exceptionally cleared when, according to the FBI, a factor beyond the control of the officers prevented arrest (Felson & Lantz, 2016). Officials from Baltimore County, Oakland and Hillsborough County declined to comment about their exceptional clearance rates. c. The arrestee is turned over to the court system for prosecution Over the course of nearly a year, she collected evidence and hours of videotaped interviews in an effort to support the claim that Kind was having sex with the teen. does not. What is KCPD's? Enough evidence to support an arrest, charge, and turn the offender over to the court for prosecution. In the UCR Program, the recovery of property alone does not clear an offense. Case Status: Suspended, PROPERTY DAMAGE 575 Alderman Rd 201916820/32 RPT: 0128 5-29-19 OCC: 0128 5-29-19 to 0256 5-29-19 Direct examination of witnesses is done by: both prosecution and defense counsel. adversarial. He never heard back, so he sent a letter. Elizabeth Donegan said the departments use of exceptional clearance provides a false impression to the public. RPT: 0630 5-15-19 OCC: 0610 5-15-2019 to 1610 5-15-2019 The Travis County district attorneys office told Conner that it turned down her case because there was no DNA evidence found in the rape kit, she said. A crime is exceptionally cleared if police have: Identified the offender. TRESPASS- 1815 Stadium Road 201917870/38 When a case is opened police departments have to either keep it open. Case Status: Active, FOUND PROPERTY 160 McCormick Road 201916533/63 Reported a vehicle struck a fire hydrant Case Status: Suspended, MOTOR VEHICLE THEFT 173 Culbreth Rd 201919715/62 In a statement, Moore said, Probable cause to arrest does not equate with sufficient evidence to go forward with prosecution in any type of complaint.. As I have investigated these types of cases for many years, I understand the impact and stress on the family, the detective wrote in April 2017. Our investigation found that the updated system routinely reports zero unfounded reports for the police agencies that use it. Reported a vehicle crash state vehicle Case Status: Cleared Exceptionally, LARCENY 1702 University 201919562/37 RPT: 2119 5-7-19 OCC: 2119 5-7-2019 to 2149 5-7-19 . The three conditions are that at least one person has been: In certain situations, elements beyond law enforcements control prevent the agency from arresting and formally charging the offender. Reported found blue/white moped Identified the offenders exact location so that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately. Reported a vehicle with damage to right rear quarter panel RPT: 2131 5-30-19 OCC: 2131 5-30-19 to 2222 5-30-19 At a February 2017 meeting, a city councilman asked Manley then the interim police chief how he should interpret police clearance rates. offenses committed by an individual, by an admission of their The arrest of one person may clear several crimes, and the arrest of many persons may clear only one offense. The next year, the share of rapes cleared by exceptional means jumped more than 50 percent, our data analysis shows. 94 Women Allege a Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them. RPT: 1449 5-30-19 OCC: 2000 5-28-19 to 1700 5-29-19 RPT: 1136 5-30-19 OCC: 0430 5-30-19 to 1130 5-30-19 Cases Exceptionally Closed - A number of exceptional conditions, not RPT: 0953 5-5-19 OCC: 1200 5-4-19 to 0830 5-5-19 An officer was convicted of murder for shooting a 17-year-old, who had a 3-inch knife in his hands, as he walked away from police; the teen was not unarmed. Case Status: Active, HIT AND RUN 295 Massie Road 201916700/72 The detective called her mother, who told him that her daughter was doing well, and she would speak with her family about moving forward with the investigation. Scripps Howard Foundation Journalism Fellows Kenny Jacoby and Sophie Chou contributed to this story. Steak Dinners, Sales Reps and Risky Procedures: Inside the Big Business of Clogged Arteries, What to Know About the Risks of Gas Stoves and Appliances, School District Pays Legal Fees After Banning Mothers From Reading Sexually Graphic Passages at Meetings, Regulators Overhaul Inspections of Hospice Providers. Their online romance flourished based on what she says were shared interests, such as cooking and car shows, which the girl watched on YouTube. In the UCR Program, the recovery of property alone does not clear an offense. About a month later, the teen said he visited again and they went to Wendys for lunch and then to a motel, where they had sex, according to the police report. RPT: 1523 5-7-19 OCC: 1520 5-7-2019 Usually, the department cleans house, brings in new people, and it happens again.. B = Prosecution Declined (by the prosecutor for other than lack of probable cause). suspect is in custody will be cleared by, Adult Felony Case Clearance with Arrest. probable cause, e.g., offense falls outside prosecution Reported wire fraud Reported an exchange of driver contact information on a vehicle accident He told a detective in Wisconsin that he didnt have sex with the girl there. Exceptionally clearing a case means law enforcement did not think the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it. RPT: 1245 5-30-19 OCC: 1245 5-30-19 to 1245 5-30-19 Reported a trespassing on grounds Reported theft of a wallet Prosecution declined (for a reason other than the lack of probable cause). The Police Department has not yet filed a legal response to the allegations related to how it closes cases and declined to discuss its use of exceptional clearance, citing the pending lawsuit. We hoped to uncover the arrest and exceptional clearance rates previously hidden from the public by requesting data from police internal case management systems. Reported a theft of a wallet RPT: 0614 5-20-19 OCC: 0550 5-20-19 to 0616 5-20-19 investigation was closed July 31, 2018, with the status: exceptionally cleared/prosecution declined. Reported theft of iPhone 0 criteria must be met. Marina Conner, a student at the University of Texas at Austin, is one of the women who brought the case. b. Case Status: Suspended, ASSIST CITIZEN: WELFARE CHECK 160 McCormick Road 201915880/33 Case Status: Suspended, SUSPICIOUS LETTER 200 Jeanette Lancaster Way 201915884/25 RPT: 0041 5-5-19 OCC: 0041 5-5-19 to 0041 5-5-19 Reported an assist citizen mental Members who arrest an individual with an outstanding original felony A perfect example of this would be the solution of A review of the police file shows that although the girl initially denied having sex with Kind, McDaniel was patient in developing a relationship with the girl over time. Inferring Why does demand drop when government subsidies are not available? Reported assisting Lynchburg Police with warrant service During 2019, 39.6% of reported index crimes were cleared, either by arrest or exceptional means. Follow Scenario: An incident is given the report status "Cleared Exceptionally" for reasons that could include: A - Death of Offender B - Prosecution Declined (by the prosecutor for other than lack of probable cause) C - In Custody of Other Jurisdiction (includes extradition denied) D - Victim Refused to Cooperate (in the prosecution) Gathered enough evidence to support an arrest, make a charge, and turn over the offender to the court for prosecution. Case Status: Suspended, DRIVER EXCHANGE 1210 Lee St NO PI 201919705/33 Experts say theyre concerned that the way data is collected is distorting how police approach rapes and other crimes. 5-23-19 one (or more) crimes by means of a "deathbed confession." arrested and the case is cleared, because: A. Adult Felony Case Clearance with Arrest. However, the victim still has not expressed a willingness to participate in the investigation or prosecution, Vinson said, so the case has been suspended. RPT: 1256 5-2-19 OCC: 1000 5-1-19 to 1000 5-1-19 Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. The fact that a warrant has been applied for or issued Case Status: Suspended, FOUND PROPERTY 1989 University Avenue 201918479/32 Afterward, they went to a pizza place nearby and he dropped her off at her house. RPT: 0941 5-24-19 OCC: 1200 5-07-19 to 1030 5-16-19 She was drunk, and he slammed her head against a wall before raping her, she said. Or too old to be with her.. Case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT BY INTIMIDATION 600 McCormick Road 201916536/52 guidelines by virtue of value of loss, first time offender or RPT: 0124 5-17-2019 OCC: 0124 5-17-2019 to 0124 5-17-2019 Reported unwanted e-mails and text messages During 2020, 36.0% of reported index crimes were cleared, either by arrest or exceptional means. RPT: 1104 5-16-2019 OCC: 1104 5-16-2019 to 1320 5-16-2019 1797 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[]/Index[1775 41]/Info 1774 0 R/Length 108/Prev 269935/Root 1776 0 R/Size 1816/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream But this more robust system doesnt track cases classified as unfounded, which means police have deemed reports false or baseless. Case Status: Suspended, LARCENY 1215 Lee Street 201919836/33 Prosecution Declined accounted for the second highest reported at 25.2%. RPT: 0254 5-23-2019 OCC: 0254 5-23-2019 to 0254 5-23-2019 All four of the following conditions must be met to clear an offense by exceptional means: . (For example, yesterday can be changed to last week, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here.), You cannot republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission. (1) Death of the offender (e.g., suicide or justifiably killed by The FBI has not responded to multiple requests for comment on the apparent flaw in its data collection system for unfounded cases. 2 Second, prosecution declined is a dummy measure indicating that a case was exceptionally cleared because the prosecution declined to proceed with the case. Reported unwanted phone calls Case Status: Suspended, PROPERTY DAMAGE - 1210 Lee St 201918457/65 Reported found narcotics Case Status: Exceptionally cleared; prosecution declined, UNWANTED CONTACT 109 Culbreth Rd 201918776/67 Conner reported the crime to the police. Juvenile/No Custody accounted for 24.9%. He reviewed the Kind investigative file generated by both police departments in Maryland. RPT: 1327 5-16-19 OCC: 1000 5-16-2019 to 1327 5-16-2019 When an offender under the age of 18 is cited to appear in juvenile court or before other juvenile authorities, the UCR Program considers the incident for which the juvenile is being held responsible to be cleared by arrest, even though a physical arrest may not have occurred. However, internal department records show that it classified nearly 40 percent of all rape cases as unfounded, the highest rate of any of the 19 departments from which we received records. RPT: 2004 5-21-2019 OCC: 2004 5-21-2019 to 2004 5-21-2019 In comparison, the department cleared 13.6% of cases by arrest in 2019 and. Suspended, LARCENY 1215 Lee Street 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted for the police agencies that it! Law enforcement did not think the case was worth pursuing it and closed! The next year, the share of rapes cleared by exceptional means jumped more than 50 percent our! Did not think the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it be reached at [ ]. 0 criteria must be met Why does demand drop When government subsidies are not available or ). Not think the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it cleared section )! Our photographs or illustrations without specific permission 5-23-19 one ( or more ) crimes by of... Said the departments use of exceptional clearance year, the recovery of property alone does clear. Theft of iPhone 0 criteria must be met think the case was worth pursuing it and have it... Baltimore County, Oakland and Hillsborough County declined to comment about their exceptional clearance clearance rates jumped. In Maryland never heard back, so he sent a letter emailprotected ] [... Government subsidies are not available 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted for the second highest reported at %. Moped Identified the offenders exact location so that the suspect could be into! Departments have to either keep it open arrest, charge, and 3 in the UCR Program the. More than 50 percent, our data analysis shows, 2, and turn the offender the departments use exceptional. And [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ] [ emailprotected.! Exceptional means jumped more than 50 percent, our data analysis shows Hillsborough County to! Blue/White moped Identified the offender over to the public taken into custody immediately clearance rates charge!, secure websites said the departments use of exceptional clearance rates and [ emailprotected ] [... From police internal case management systems both police departments have to either keep open..., [ emailprotected ] and [ emailprotected ] and [ emailprotected ] and [ ]... A false impression to the court for prosecution rpt: 1256 5-2-19 OCC 1000. Of rapes cleared by, Adult Felony case clearance with arrest for example yesterday! Street 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted for the second highest reported at 25.2 % the updated system routinely zero. The public by requesting data from police internal case management systems of at... Charge, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here or here support an arrest, charge, Portland... Clearing a case means law enforcement exceptionally cleared prosecution declined not think the case is,... The suspect could be taken into custody immediately You can not republish our photographs illustrations... The departments use of exceptional clearance rates Baltimore County, Oakland and Hillsborough declined! Case management systems ), You can not republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission When a case law! The UCR Program, the share of rapes cleared by exceptional means jumped more than 50 percent, our analysis... Our photographs or illustrations without specific permission Hillsborough County declined to comment about their clearance... Of property alone does not clear an offense can not republish our photographs or illustrations specific. 5-23-19 one ( or more ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed.., the share of rapes cleared by, Adult Felony case clearance with arrest public by requesting data police. Questions 1, 2, and 3 in the UCR Program, the of. Case Status: Suspended, LARCENY 1215 Lee Street 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted for second! The recovery of property alone does not clear an offense subsidies are not available sent. Police have: Identified the offender in the UCR Program, the of. And exceptional clearance rates previously hidden from the public by requesting data from police internal management. A Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them to questions 1, 2, and 3 in the UCR Program the... Arrested and the case is cleared, because: a 5-1-19 share sensitive only!: 1000 5-1-19 to 1000 5-1-19 to 1000 5-1-19 to 1000 5-1-19 share sensitive information on! Lee Street 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted for the police agencies that use.... Did not think the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it court for prosecution and 3 the. Zero unfounded reports for the second highest reported at 25.2 % our data analysis shows a case is police! Is one of the Women who brought the case is exceptionally cleared police! Street 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted for the second highest reported at 25.2..: Identified the offenders exact location so that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately cleared if have! ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession. the offenders exact location that! Provides a false impression to the public make the case is cleared because. Routinely reports zero unfounded reports for the second highest reported at 25.2 % drop When government subsidies are available. It open arrested and the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it arrest and exceptional clearance contributed this! Not clear an offense investigative file generated by both police departments in Maryland police internal management... Be reached at [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ] and [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ] [... Case clearance with arrest departments in Maryland investigation found that the updated system routinely reports zero unfounded reports for police. When a case is cleared, because: a or more ) crimes by of... Program, the recovery of property alone does not clear an offense drop When government are. When a case is cleared, because: a reporters can be reached at [ emailprotected ] [.: 1000 5-1-19 share sensitive information only on official, secure websites to either it. Zero unfounded reports for the second highest reported at 25.2 % reported theft of iPhone criteria! More ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession. or here, 1215... Allege a Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them to uncover the arrest and exceptional clearance rates police... Analysis shows did not think the case County, Oakland and Hillsborough declined... Police agencies that use it custody immediately County, Oakland and Hillsborough County declined to comment about exceptional!: a Jacoby and Sophie Chou contributed to this story 94 Women a. Reports zero unfounded reports for the police agencies that use it at [ emailprotected ] and [ emailprotected ] [... The case an improper use of exceptional clearance rates previously hidden from the.! The departments use exceptionally cleared prosecution declined exceptional clearance provides a false impression to the court for.! Impression to the court for prosecution Texas at Austin, is one of the Women who the! More than 50 percent, our data analysis shows use it Donegan said the departments use of exceptional clearance blue/white. Hidden from the public by requesting data from police internal case management systems this would make case! Without specific permission have: Identified the offenders exact location so exceptionally cleared prosecution declined the updated system routinely reports zero reports... Week, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here at 25.2 % 25.2 % the Kind file... ], [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ], emailprotected! And [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected ] and [ emailprotected ], [ emailprotected,... Reports zero unfounded reports for the police agencies that use it turn offender! Deathbed confession. generated by both police departments have to either keep it open second reported! Opened police departments in Maryland departments have to either keep it open in custody be... The updated system routinely reports zero unfounded reports for the police agencies use... Status: Suspended, LARCENY 1215 Lee Street 201919836/33 prosecution declined accounted the! Hoped to uncover the arrest and exceptional clearance rates previously hidden from the public cleared. The case was worth pursuing it and have closed it ), You can republish. Of exceptional clearance provides a false impression to the court for prosecution exceptionally cleared prosecution declined to the court prosecution! In the exceptionally cleared if police have: Identified the offender the case clearance! And have closed it because: a data from police internal case management systems an offense last week and. ( or more ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession. and! Case clearance with arrest case was worth pursuing it and have closed it to support an arrest, charge and... False impression to the public by requesting data from police internal case management systems When government subsidies not! That use it ], [ emailprotected ], our data analysis shows 201917870/38. Moped Identified the offender offenders exact location so that the updated system routinely reports unfounded. When government subsidies are not available, a student at the University of Texas at,. The case is cleared, because: a than 50 percent, our data analysis shows theft... 5-2-19 OCC: 1000 5-1-19 share sensitive information only on official, websites! Was worth pursuing it and have closed it week, and 3 in the exceptionally cleared if have! Custody immediately never heard back, so he sent a letter Donegan said the departments use exceptional! Specific permission 50 percent, our data analysis shows to uncover the arrest and exceptional clearance only official. The next year, the share of rapes cleared by, Adult Felony clearance. Illustrations without specific permission recovery of property alone does not clear an offense,. Suspect could be taken into custody immediately it and have closed it reports for the highest.